The difference between a gift card and a prepaid debit card
-
Hereβs a clear breakdown of the difference between a gift card and a prepaid debit card:
Gift Card vs
Prepaid Debit Card
- Usage Scope
Gift Card
Usually closed-loop β works only at a specific store/brand (e.g., Amazon, Starbucks, Walmart).
Some are open-loop (Visa/Mastercard gift cards), usable anywhere those networks are accepted.
Prepaid Debit Card
Always open-loop β works anywhere that accepts the payment network (Visa, Mastercard, AmEx, Discover).
Can also withdraw cash from ATMs.
- Reloadability
Gift Card
Usually not reloadable. Once the balance is used up, the card is useless.
Some retailer gift cards allow reload, but thatβs less common.
Prepaid Debit Card
Reloadable β you can keep adding money via bank transfer, direct deposit, or cash reloads.
- Identification / Registration
Gift Card
Often anonymous (no ID or personal details needed).
Limited protections if lost or stolen.
Prepaid Debit Card
Requires registration with your name, address, sometimes SSN/ID (depending on the country).
Comes with fraud protection and dispute rights similar to bank debit cards.
- Expiration & Fees
Gift Card
May have expiration dates or inactivity fees (depending on local law).
No monthly fees.
Prepaid Debit Card
Usually no expiration (as long as you keep using/reloading).
May have monthly maintenance fees, ATM withdrawal fees, or reload fees.
- Best Use Cases
Gift Card
:
Giving someone a present.
Shopping at a specific retailer.
Short-term use.
Prepaid Debit Card
:
Alternative to a bank account.
Budget control (load only what you want to spend).
Travel money or online purchases.
Summary:
Gift cards are limited, single-purpose, and often one-time use.
Prepaid debit cards are flexible, reloadable, and function like a normal debit card.